Pitfalls When Writing YA Christian Fiction

Because most novels for teens are written by adults, they sometimes forget what they liked to read as teens. In YA Christian fiction, adult authors want to produce novels that contrast or contradict themes in the secular market. But that attitude can lead to pitfalls when writing YA Christian fiction.

Too Perfect?

The key to creating a main character for a YA novel is to make them likable and relatable. But sometimes adults authors want to make their teen main characters (MC) role models for teen readers. That’s not bad in itself. But if authors think the only way to create a role model is to create a perfect main character, the story will suffer for it and turn away readers. A perfect teen MC is not relatable and eventually will become unlikable. All major characters need flaws and giving the MC of a Christian fiction novel flaws makes them human.

Too Easy?

Teen MCs also need to wrestle with their problems. Giving a teen a problem that is solved simply by listening to an adult is not only unrealistic but also undramatic. As a parent of teens, I know full well there are times I’m not sure what advice to give my kids. Or I do know what they should and tell them, but then I have to let them come to agreeing with that view in their own way and in their own time.

Since I have to let my own teens struggle with their own problems, I should do the same for my teen MC and, honestly, all my characters. Authors of YA Christian fiction need to show how our faith works in a complicated world. Our faith does have the answers, but often it’s a struggle to discover what that answer is, and teen readers benefit when they see teen MCs with struggles they can relate to.

Many rookie authors, regardless of genre, have a hard time letting the characters they like suffer. But the suffering and struggle is what makes the characters grow and is the gas that propels the story vehicle.

What do you think? Should characters be flawed and struggle? Writers, is it hard to make your characters flawed and give them struggles?

Here are more tips on writing Christian fiction.