Guide to Tracking the Plot When Writing a Mystery

The complexities of a mystery plot can scare off writers. But with organization, you can keep track of the twists and turns and avoid even the smallest holes in your plot. Follow the tips in this guide to tracking the plot when writing a mystery.

Write down characters’ movements–whether they appear in the novel or not.

What do I mean by the above statement? I write from the first-person POV of my amateur sleuth, Rae Riley. Readers follow the mystery only from her perspective. But as the author of the novel, I need to know what all the major characters are doing when they aren’t on the page. It makes the movements and dialogue that do appear in print more realistic and believable.

This is especially true for the culprit of my mystery. I like to write down what he or she is doing while Rae conducts her investigation. Rae can’t possibly know every move the culprit makes before, during, and after he commits the crime. But since I do as the author, I know what’s critical for Rae to uncover during the course of the story.

For example, let’s say I need Rae to see a blue convertible on a particular day. The most plausible way for her to see it is in the town where she works. So I write a scene where she goes to work at the library and has lunch with a friend and spots the car

But how did the car get there? On the right, I write what the other characters have done so Rae can see the convertible in town. Those reasons may not have to appear in the book for readers to make sense of the mystery, but it helps me understand my plot and the motivation of my characters.

You can break this technique down to hours or even minutes if your plotting requires it.

Another example: you’re writing a mystery in which someone had to have been murdered between 11 and 11:30 p.m. Select your day and then the times to schedule what the detective, victim, culprit, and suspects were doing.

Again, not all that action may appear in the final draft, but it helps me keep track of what my characters are doing.

Plot with a calendar.

The seasons of the year my mysteries are set are critical to the story. For example, for my Halloween mystery, A Riddle in the Lonesome October, I knew I wanted it to end on Halloween. Rae’s uncle has a serious riding accident on the first day of the novel, so I also knew I needed a realistic timeline for his recovery. On top of that, Rae is trying to solve a riddle involving a lost inheritance. So her progress should occur over a believable period of time.

Using a calendar, paper or digital, is a great way to track all those points when a mystery that takes place over weeks instead of days. You can see what each character is doing each day and if the story is unfolding at a reasonable pace.

In Riddle, I have something occur every day for about two weeks. Then I jump ahead in time by a week as I build to the climax on Halloween. There were several reasons for the jump: Rae’s uncle needed time to heal, the family is frantically helping Rae’s aunt with the harvest that her farmer uncle can’t perform this fall, and Rae’s dad, the sheriff, is getting nowhere in his criminal investigation. All those facts needed to be addressed, but I didn’t need scene after scene showing them. I summed up a week, and then plunged into the next important scene in the mystery. Having a calendar to make clear where I jumped and what had gone on during that period was very helpful.

Writers, how do you keep track of plot when writing a mystery?

Here are all my tips and prompts for this month’s theme of writing mysteries.

Writing a Detective Duo: 3 Key Steps for Mystery Writers 

If you want to write a mystery, I’ll state the obvious: you must have a detective. But detectives come in all shapes and sizes, so you have a lot of room to maneuver. As you write, you might find your story is better if you have a duo of detectives. When I began my first novel, my detective was 19-year-old Rae Riley. Since my mystery was aimed at teens, my amateur detective had to be one. But as I wrote, I realized Rae’s father, since he is the sheriff of their fictional Ohio county, had to join her in the investigation or else he’d look incompetent. So I stumbled into a mystery-solving team, and my stories are the better for it. So here’s my writing a detective duo: 3 key steps for mystery writers

Decide if you write from the POV of one member or both.

POV (point of view) is critical to how you plot your mystery. Rae is my main character, and I write in first person. The story has to happen to her, and she has to make the story happen. Her father, Mal, can provide her information, but readers only see him through her eyes. 

If I was writing from both of their POVs, then I could have scenes with just Mal and have him discover things that Rae may not be aware of, but the reader would be. Who my POV character is and how many I have affects how I lay out the clues.

The team should have contrasts.

If you’re two detectives are too much alike, then you only need one of them. Holmes and Watson have appealed to readers for over a century because the characters contrast.

Rae is a quiet, thoughtful amateur photographer. She has a photographer’s eye for noticing details. She also has a drive to help people, which draws her into cases.

Mal is more outgoing, confident, and carries a lot of authority in his manner. He’s also very protective, especially of his children.

Because of the contrasts in personality …

The team should have conflict.

Nothing’s more boring than two characters who never disagree. One of the delights in the Nero Wolfe mystery series is how the eccentricities and quirks of the great detective Nero Wolfe aggravate his right-hand man Archie Goodwin.

Rae’s desire to help people in trouble brings her into conflict with Mal, who wants her to stay safe. This conflict brings some needed tension to a warm relationship that could get too cozy to stay interesting.

Creating a detective team is a lot of work but a lot of fun. What detective teams do you love to read?

Struggling with First Chapters? My 3 Tips on How to Write a Compelling Mystery Opening

If you love mysteries, maybe you’ve had the dream of writing one. But how do you start the story? Are you struggling with first chapters? My 3 tips on how to write a compelling mystery opening are here to help.

The first chapter does not have to end with discovering a body.

Many cozy mysteries begin with the amateur sleuth meeting the perfectly repellent victim, who is then found dead at the end of the first chapter. Nothing wrong with starting a mystery novel that way, but it is not an iron-clad rule. If that kind of opening isn’t working for your mystery, keep reading. A rule that you usually should follow is …

The first chapter should contain the main problem of the mystery.

What do I mean by the main problem? It’s the problem that fuels the mystery. In my Halloween mystery, A Riddle in the Lonesome October, a lost inheritance leads to all sorts of crimes. In the first chapter, I explain the backstory of the lost inheritance and readers meet two of the people who could inherit it. Right away, readers know what kind of mystery is involved and several of the major characters.

Let’s go back to our perfectly repellent victim. In the first chapter, I could show how perfectly repellent the victim is. In a small town in West Virginia, the victim is a developer of a new ski resort. The town is divided over whether the resort is good or bad for the community. Although no crime has been committed by the end of the first chapter, readers know the developer and his plans will be central to the mystery.

Introduce the culprit early in the story.

Although you don’t need a body at the end of the first chapter, you should introduce the culprit early and before the major crime of the novel.

Here’s an example of how NOT to do it: The murder happens on page 40. The amateur sleuth or cop begins the investigation. The culprit isn’t introduced until page 120. Mystery fans who love fair-play mysteries will call, “Foul!’

Why? Because it seems like the author wasn’t playing fair. For 80 pages, readers were trying to figure out the crime, but there was no way they could because they hadn’t met the culprit yet.

The exception to this rule is if the major crime happens very early in the novel. If a body is discovered at the end of Chapter 1, then readers know they will be spending the rest of the book meeting all the suspects. This seems fair. But you still want to introduce the culprit early so he or she has time to interact with the detective. After finishing a novel, readers love to flip back through a mystery and appreciate how the culprit sparred with the detective.

If you’re a mystery fan, what do you think is the best way to write the beginning of a mystery novel?

Here are more tips on writing mysteries.

Is Your Story a Short Story or a Novel?

If you’re a new writer, or even a more seasoned one, and you have a new idea for a story, you may wonder: is your story a short story or novel? Like most things in art, there are few hard and fast rules in writing. But below are some questions to ask yourself if you’re unsure whether your narrative is better suited to the form of a short story or novel.

How big is your cast of characters?

A good rule of thumb is the more characters your story has, the more likely you need a novel to give them the space for readers to get to know them.

Does your story have a subplot?

The short story has one plot. In a mystery short story, it could be who shot Old Man Thompson. There are no subplots. Because of the short form, everything in the short story has to work at solving the mystery. If you want to develop subplots, you’ll have to write a novel.

How complicated is your story?

This is related to the question above but not the same. In a short story, my clues for solving the mystery of who shot Old Man Thompson will have to be fewer and possibly more simple. I’ll have fewer suspects. If I wrote this story in a novel, I would have room to add more clues, more suspects, maybe additional crimes, like a murderous assault or a theft.

How much time does your story cover?

A story covering a year or years probably needs a novel. But not always. You could write a short story covering that much time, but you would have to write telling scenes selected from those years. For example, you wrote a story about a father and son’s reconciliation and you use Christmas celebrations to chart the repair of that relationship. In a novel, you would have time to show what happens between each Christmas. In a short story, you would have to confine yourself to just the scenes at Christmas.

Do you find yourself padding?

If you’re adding characters or scenes just to meet a word count, then you probably have a short story or novella on your hands. My favorite mystery series is Nero Wolfe mysteries by Rex Stout. A fan of the series once wrote that Mr. Stout was a master of the novella but some of his novels weren’t quite as good. He often put in padding. Some of it is very entertaining and very funny padding. For example, in the novel Some Buried Caesar, Archie Goodwin, assistant to the great detective Nero Wolfe, is arrested and has to spend time in a jail. He and another prisoner decide to start a prisoners’ union in order to improve conditions. It’s fun but doesn’t have anything to do with the plot.

The most important thing to remember when deciding whether your idea is a better fit for a short story or novel is …

Which form best serves the story?

If you write fiction, you have to make story king. That means if a metaphor you love doesn’t serve the story, you cut it out. If your favorite quirky character is killing the pace, you remove him. If you find yourself inventing boring dialogue to fill a word count, you eliminate it.

One technique I’ve found helpful is to write a one to three sentence summary of what the story is about. For my first novel, A Shadow on the Snow, the summary is “Nineteen-year-old Rae Riley needs to discover who is sending her increasingly threatening anonymous notes.” As I wrote a section or edited one, I had to ask myself if it served the basic premise of the story. If it didn’t, I either needed to cut it or adapt it.

Have you read a short story that might have been better as a novel? Or a novel that should have been a short story?

Here are tips and prompts for writing short stories.

Four Tips for Creating a Teen Detective

I’m guest blogging today on American Christian Fiction Writers with four tips for creating a teen detective.

Since 2018, I’ve spent every day with my teen detective Rae Riley. She’s had a cameo in one short story and been featured in another as well as three novels. My latest novel, A Riddle in the Lonesome October, released October 1. After working with her for so long, here are four tips for creating an engaging teen detective.

Read my whole post on the essentials of a teen sleuth here. And here is my previous guest blog, researching cozy mysteries.

Click the link for more advice and tips for writing mysteries.

Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑