Book Rec: The Murder of Roger Ackroyd

Every October, it’s mystery month on JPC Allen Writes. If you love classic mysteries, I have a book rec: The Murder of Roger Ackroyd by Agatha Christie. This novel came early in her career, published only six years after her first novel. But this is the novel that proved Mrs. Christie was the Queen of Crime with a solution so controversial and original that it made many critics cry, “Foul!”. Today, it’s recognized for the brilliant twist that it is.

The novel is narrated by Dr. James Sheppard, a country doctor in the tiny English town of KIng’s Abbott. Not much happens in the town, and Dr. Sheppard was wry attitude toward the main hobby of most of the town’s residents, including his sister: gossip.

The town is shocked when a local wealthy woman, Mrs. Ferrars, is found dead, apparently a suicide. In the year since her husband’s death, she’d been seeing Roger Ackroyd, a rich businessman with a home in the area, and everyone in town expected them to soon announce their engagement. When Dr. Sheppard meets Ackroyd in town, he can see how hard the news of Mrs. Ferrars’s death has hit him. Ackroyd says he needs to speak to the doctor and invites him to dinner that night at his mansion, Fernly Park.

At the dinner, readers meet the rest of Ackroyd’s household: his sister-in-law, her daughter, his secretary, housekeeper, and butler, and a houseguest who is a big game hunter. After the meal, Ackroyd takes Sheppard into his study and tells him he knows why Mrs. Ferrars took her life. She had poisoned her abusive husband last year and someone had been blackmailing her because of it. She hadn’t given Ackroyd the name when she’d confessed to him, but now Ackroyd has just received a letter from her, which he hadn’t opened yet. He tells Sheppard he’ll read it when he’s alone.

Dr. Sheppard leaves the house, only to receive a call at home from the butler, saying Roger Ackroyd has been murdered. He races back to Fernly Park, but when the butler answers the door, he says he made no such call. Ackroyd is still in his study. Dr. Sheppard wants to make sure Ackroyd is all right. When his knocks and calls provoke no response, they break in the door and find Roger Ackroyd stabbed to death.

Although the police are called in, Ackroyd’s niece hires Sheppard’s new neighbor to look into the case: retired detective Hercule Poirot. Poirot usually worked with his friend Hastings when he solved cases, but Hastings now lives in Argentina. So Sheppard falls into the role of Watson to Poirot’s Sherlock Holmes, recording the progress of the case and providing Poirot with information only a local would have.

The murderer weaved an intricate crime, but not a perfect one. Poirot works his way through the tangle with a solution no one saw coming when the novel was published in 1926. Each time I read it, I marvel at how Mrs. Christie writes a fair-play mystery, with all the clues available to readers, and still yanks the rug out from under us.

If you love classic mysteries, which novels are your favorites?

Here are more of my recommendations of mystery books.

What Genre Would You Place This Scene In?

What genre would you place this scene in? The young woman in the black coat looks afraid, and the backpack on the ground makes me think of a clandestine exchange taking place, so thriller or crime drama is the genre that leaps to my mind. But I’m encouraging you to think outside the box.

When I take a closer look, the man is carrying a backpack that looks feminine. The one on the ground looks more like one a man would carry. And during this confrontation, the woman in the white coat decides to light up. I think there’s possibilities for comedy here.

Let me know what genre you would place this scene in?

Here are more photo prompts for writing scenes.

How to Write a First Chapter Filled with Tension: A Step-by-Step Guide

As I’ve said in previous posts, tension is the key to hooking and keeping readers. To show you exactly how to write a first chapter filled with tension, step by step, I have annotated the first chapter of my second novel, A Storm of Doubts.

“Just stop it!” 

Here’s my hook. In a mystery, if someone yells a line like that, readers are prepared for trouble. So there’s tension in the first sentence.

The shout made me jerk and get poked by a dead branch of a honeysuckle bush. 

Wasn’t that a woman’s voice? Not a girl’s, not my cousin Coral’s. 

My protagonist is asking questions, concerned about her cousin. This adds tension.

Swiveling on my hips, I sat higher and caught strands of my dark gold hair on the bush. The fox cubs or kits or whatevers I’d been photographing leaped and rolled over each other between muted beams of sunlight, undisturbed. 

This description is to orient readers in the story world.

Two voices, one higher, one lower, slipped through the budding understory shrubs and bushes. 

Back to the voices, adding description to add tension.

Who would be out in the woods on the morning of Memorial Day between my cousin’s farm and my dad’s? If we were still on family land. Coral knew exactly where we were, which was why I’d asked her to guide me after she told me about the fox babies. But Coral didn’t care much for civilization and nothing at all for ridiculous things like property boundaries. 

More questions from the protagonist to increase tension and set the scene. Also how the protagonist describes the situation allows readers to get to know her.

“Coral?” I called, long, white honeysuckle blossoms brushing my cheeks, their thick Easter-y scent clogging my nose. 

When had she left me? I couldn’t have been photographing foxes that long. Although she was the guide, she was only twelve, and I was just a day short of twenty. So it was my responsibility to return Coral home in pristine condition. 

More questions and scene setting. And humor because that’s part of my protagonist’s personality.

The voices continued, but too quiet for me to catch any words, their murmur blending with the faint rustle of leaves in the morning breeze. 

So Coral might have met someone. But she knew not to talk to strangers. 

I collected my camera and the small tripod it sat on and eased myself backward through the thicket. 

Did not talking to strangers still apply if you met one in the middle of nowhere in the middle of a county as rural as Marlin County, Ohio? 

“Coral?” I ticked up the volume. 

Ticking up the volume also ticks up the tension.

“Leave me alone!” The woman’s voice again. She sounded desperate, not angry. 

The women’s words and how she says them adds more tension.

“Did you call me, Rae?” Coral seemed to pop out of the morning air. She could move like a ghost in the woods. 

Coral’s appearance de-escalates the tension because now Rae knows at least her cousin is okay.

“I wondered where you were.” I closed my tripod. “Did you hear that yell? It sounds like somebody’s in trouble.” 

Removing her baseball hat with a galloping horse on the front, she wiped copper bangs from her sweaty forehead. “Naw. Just some rich chick and her boyfriend.” 

My cousin Amber had mentioned that high school kids used an abandoned bridge as a party site. 

“Did you talk to them?” I placed the camera inside my padded backpack. 

“Nope. I just heard voices and followed them to see what was going on.” 

The distant hum of conversation continued to glide through the cool morning air. 

“You stay here.” I tucked the tripod into a pouch on the outside backpack. “I’ll go see if the girl or the woman needs help.” 

Now the tension increases with Rae’s decision to check on the woman whose voice she’s heard

“She looked more like a woman. But I said she wasn’t in trouble.” 

“I know, but … well, I’d like to see for myself. I mean, if I were in a lonely spot in the woods with someone upsetting me, I’d want help. Can you lead me to them?” 

Coral squinted at me like I was a new species she’d stumbled across. Then she shrugged and headed for a short slope overgrown with young trees and dense stands of pawpaws. 

An engine roared to life. As it pulled away, another one turned over. 

Tension fades because Rae won’t be entering into this argument she’s overheard. But I have to add new tension to keep the scene moving.

“Hold on, Coral.” I unzipped a pocket of my cargo pants. “It sounds like they—” Looking at the time on my phone, I gasped. “Coral, can we get back to your farm in twenty minutes?” 

Rae’s gasp indicates something else is wrong. which means tension.

“What’s the rush?” 

I stared at her. “Amber and Dad are marching in the Memorial Day parade. He won’t be upset if we miss him, but Amber will be. I promised her I’d take pictures.” 

Coral rolled her brown eyes. “Oh, yeah, I forgot. But she won’t care if I don’t come. She can’t stand me.” 

“That’s not true.” At least, not completely true. The fights Amber and Coral had were more intense than the spats I’d witnessed between my three half-brothers. “Can we get back in time to ride into town with your parents?” 

Coral studied a slug on a rotten log, a frown puckering her pretty, freckled face. “I don’t think so.” Now she looked worried, probably thinking that Uncle Hank and Aunt Jeanine would believe she deliberately wandered away to miss her older sister’s performance with the band. 

Not a serious problem, but one with a little tension.

She raised her head. “We’re not far from Walter’s place. Do you think he’d drive us?” 

My anxiety notched a few degrees higher. 

Readers are curious about why Rae’s anxiety increased.

That all depended on what kind of mood we found our great-grandfather in. And Dad and Uncle Hank and Aunt Jeanine would not approve of us going over there without one of them. We never knew which outlaw relatives might be hanging around Walter’s house. 

But if there was trouble, Coral and I could escape to the woods. Once Coral was in her natural habitat, chances of anyone keeping up were slim. 

“Okay.” I hitched the shoulder straps of my backpack higher. “We’ll go to Walter’s.” 

Now the tension is high again because readers know Rae and Coral are heading into a potentially dangerous situation.

I spend the next page describing their hike to Walter’s house to give readers info about the outdoor setting and how remote it is. Rae can’t get any bars on her phone. Then they reach the home of their great-grandfather.

As we hurried across the patchy grass, someone opened the squeaky screen to the front door and sauntered onto the porch with a mug. 

I skidded to a halt. 

The man had shaggy, golden hair and a scruffy beard. Sipping from his mug, he studied us. 

Although I’d expected to find a few of our relatives from the outlaw branch hanging out at Walter’s house, it never occurred to me that our great-uncle Troy might be back in the county. 

And according to Dad and Gram, Troy was a synonym for trouble.

So the tension has increased even more because the possibility of encountering a criminal member of the family is now a certainty, and Uncle Troy is a particularly threatening relative. Here’s where the chapter ends.

If you have questions about how I built tension, please ask in the comments.

Here are all my posts this month on writing the beginning of a novel. 

2 Secrets for Creating a Compelling Hook for Your Novel

Before I dive into the 2 secrets for creating a compelling hook for your novel, I wanted to remind you that the theme for JPC Allen Writes during 2026 is how to write a novel. With four months behind us, we’ve covered:

This month will be about how to write the beginning of your novel. The hook is the opening line or lines that snag the attention of readers so thoroughly that they can’t put your book down. That sounds like a tall order and it is, but keep reading.

No hook? No problem.

If you can’t get past page 1 of your novel because you can’t come up with a creative hook, write a lousy one. It’s not permanent. Consider it an interim hook until the permanent hook arrives. Write your opening lines and then keep going.

Now write the whole novel.

What? What about the hook? Often, especially for first-time novelists, you have to slog through a first draft before you understand your characters and their journey through the story. Only when you’ve reached the final page are you in a position to understand how to create a hook for your particular story. Go back to your interim hook and throw it out or refine it to fit the rest of your book.

2 Secrets for Creating a Hook

The two secrets are that your hook should be meaningful and project tension. By meaningful, I mean the hook should reflect what readers should expect in your novel. The exciting opening sequence that turns out to be a dream, a flashback, or a scene on a movie set is not meaningful. Readers will feel cheated.

The best hooks also project tension, either hinting at the problem facing your protagonist that will soon become clear in the first chapters or plunking the problem in front of readers with the first line.

Here are the first line of my three novels:

A Shadow on the Snow. “I’M NOT FOOLED, RAE. YOU’RE JUST LIKE YOUR MOTHER.”

19-year-old Rae Riley receives anonymous notes that grow more threatening. That’s the mystery she has to solve, and I begin the novel with the message from the first anonymous note. I put the problem front and center in the first line.

A Storm of Doubts. “‘Just stop it!’ The shout made me jerk and get poked by a dead branch of a honeysuckle bush. Wasn’t that a woman’s voice? Not a girl’s, not my cousin Coral’s.”

Since this is a mystery, someone shouting like she’s in trouble creates immediate tension.

A Riddle in the Lonesome October. “‘We’ve got a bit of a situation here at the children’s home, Mal.’ Aunt Carrie’s voice came over the phone.”

The line of dialogue carries tension. What’s the situation? What could be happening at a children’s home? This first line hints at the tension involved in a hunt for a missing inheritance which is explained in the first chapter.

So let me know which opening lines did a great job of pulling you into a novel.

Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑