So what do I mean by using uncomfortable settings to develop characters and advance plot? The bedrock under this questions is tension–tension is the engine that propels readers from line to line, page to page, chapter to chapter. An effective way to created tension is to plunk your protagonist in a setting that makes him or her uncomfortable or uneasy. But how does this setting create tension, develop characters, and advance plot? Read on!
Creating Tension with Uncomfortable Settings
When we experience tension, we want to relieve it. Hence all the activities people engage in as stress-relievers. The same is true when reading fiction. When a reader experiences tension, she wants that tension relieves and there’s only two ways to do it: keep reading or set aside the book for good.
Placing your protagonist in a setting that makes them uncomfortable ignites questions in the readers’s mind: Why doesn’t the protagonist like where he is? Did something happen in his past? Are the people he usually find here a threat? What’s going on?
If readers are asking questions, that means they feel the tension. Most of the time, they will keep reading to answer their questions and relieve the tension.
Using Uncomfortable Settings to Develop Characters
Revealing what your protagonist doesn’t like is just as important as showing what he does like. For example, your protagonist goes to a very dingy bookstore in a sketchy part of the city. As soon as she enters the store, her thoughts reveal she is uncomfortable. In this situation, an author could introduce some backstory if her discomfort comes from an event in her past. Or she could remember unsavory rumors she’s heard about this bookstore. And yet she’s come anyway. Or the author can make it very clear that the reason the protagonist is uneasy is because of her history with the owner. All these explanations create tension and reveal something important about the main character.
Using Uncomfortable Settings to Advance the Plot
Once you’ve established your protagonist finds a setting uncomfortable, you have to explain why she is facing this setting. Using the example above, the protagonist doesn’t like this part of the city because it’s the poor part her family escaped from years ago. So why is she here? She believes the unsavory rumors she’s heard about the bookstore. So why did she come? The owner is the grandfather who disowned her mother. So why did she come?
All those why questions concern plot. As you write the scene, you can hint at the answer, perpetuating or increasing the tension. Or you can plainly answer it, but that plain answer not only releases the first tension but creates a new one.
For example, the girl visiting the bookstore owned by her estranged grandfather states why she’s come: her mother has disappeared and the cops think she’s just abandoned her. But the girl thinks some harm has come to her mom and she’s asking the only other relative she has for help. So I’ve relieved the first tension and created a second one.
What settings make you uncomfortable? If you’re a writer, how would you use them in a story?